Overview:

Highways once cut through thriving Black communities, destroying homes, businesses and cultural landmarks. Robert Bullard argues that proposed changes to federal permitting and historic preservation rules could put more of that history at risk.

Centennial Hill. Tremé. Overtown. 

Each was once a prominent middle-class African-American neighborhood in a different city. Today, a highway paves over these places where Black communities and wealth were built.

In the North as in the South, Black neighborhoods were ruthlessly destroyed in the name of new infrastructure. Whether in Montgomery, Alabama; New Orleans; Miami; or Morris Heights in New York City, African Americans have been forcibly displaced to make way for pipelines, roads, and freeways. More than two decades ago, I co-wrote a book about this oft-unspoken policy, “Highway Robbery: Transportation Racism & New Routes to Equity.” 

A lot has changed since then, including efforts to undo some of the damage. But Congress appears poised to take us backward by making it even easier to seize Black-owned land for new infrastructure projects.  

This month, the Senate is preparing to vote on the so-called Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA). The legislation is being sold as a way to lower costs and build everything from housing to transmission lines faster. 

Big Overhaul, Big Risk

It’s the biggest permitting overhaul in decades, and the Congressional Black Caucus – a body built on the idea that Black communities must have a real voice in decisions that shape our lives – must oppose it. The effects on African-American communities and our ability to build wealth are almost too disastrous to calculate.

Proponents of BAAJA claim it will boost American construction, creating new jobs and opportunities for workers while revitalizing our nation’s aging infrastructure. The legislation’s contents, however, tell a different story.

BAAJA includes a massive giveaway to the oil and gas industry known as “permitting reform,” which would allow corporations to fast-track oil, gas, and pipeline projects by weakening environmental protections and public oversight. Black and marginalized communities would be forced to shoulder the burden of this dangerous and toxic infrastructure without any of the tools to oppose it. 

For our ancestors and historic sites, the legislation shows even less respect. That’s why the National Trust for Historic Preservation strongly opposes it. 

Proponents of BAAJA claim it will boost American construction, creating new jobs and opportunities for workers while revitalizing our nation’s aging infrastructure. The legislation’s contents tell a different story.

Currently, the only federal requirement that agencies pause to consider a proposed project’s impacts on a historic site, including unmarked burial grounds of the enslaved, is Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. BAAJA would supersede Section 106 and clear the way for the wholesale destruction of historically important sites, especially those of importance to African-Americans. 

We’ve seen this horror movie before. 

My environmental justice career began in 1979 during Jimmy Carter’s presidency. That’s when I conducted research in Houston on Bean v. Southwestern Waste Management Corp., the nation’s first lawsuit using civil rights law to challenge a landfill permit. 

Back to the Future

Since the Bean case, preventing discriminatory industrial facility permitting has remained a priority for both the environmental justice and civil rights movements. The underlying premise is that communities must have a voice in decisions that affect their lives. BAAJA would reverse this belief entirely and silence citizens and entire neighborhoods. 

Laws currently in place were crafted in response to a series of injustices. Congress passed the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 in response to a spate of highways and urban renewal projects that razed historic neighborhoods. The National Environmental Policy Act in 1969 gave the public a chance to review and comment on proposed projects. The Clean Air Act in 1970 and an executive order from President Bill Clinton 24 years later directed agencies to consider environmental justice when reviewing proposed projects. 

Prior to these laws, we had redlining. 

New, multi-lane interstate highways tore through Black neighborhoods. Our homes, churches, businesses, and generations of wealth were destroyed. Decades of research subsequently found a clear link between redlining and the construction of highways and other infrastructure projects, as well as polluting industrial facilities. The persistent health disparities between white and Black communities speak for themselves. 

That’s why the Congressional Black Caucus must stand up for Black communities, our wealth and our ancestors by rebuking the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. They should vote down the legislation, declaring that it would build the next economy on the desecrated resting grounds of enslaved ancestors and on the sites of historic Black communities, sacrificing our health in the process.

Together, we can stop BAAJA, preserve our past and protect our future. 

Dr. Robert D. Bullard is a distinguished professor of Urban Planning and Environmental Policy and director of the Bullard Center for Environmental and Climate Justice at Texas Southern University. Known as the father of environmental justice, Bullard is the former dean of the Barbara Jordan-Mickey Leland School of Public Affairs at TSU.

A veteran journalist, political analyst, and essayist, Joseph Williams has been published in a wide range of publications, including The New York Times, The Washington Post, Politico, The Boston Globe, The Atlantic, and US News & World Report. A California native, Williams is a graduate of the University Of Richmond and a former Nieman Fellow at Harvard University. He lives and works in metro Washington, D.C.