Overview:

More than a decade after a white supremacist murdered nine Black worshippers at Mother Emanuel AME Church, a $25 million memorial opens in Charleston, honoring their lives while transforming a place of unimaginable grief into one of remembrance and hope.

CHARLESTON, S.C. — Before there were sweeping marble benches, a fountain bearing nine names or gates opening onto sacred ground, there were people determined that hatred would not have the final word.

In the aftermath of the June 17, 2015, murders of nine Black worshippers during Bible study at Mother Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church, church leaders and Charleston neighbors began considering how to honor the lives taken and the people left to carry their stories.

Those conversations became the groundwork for the Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation and, eventually, the Emanuel Nine Memorial, which opened to the public Nov. 14.

LEARN MORE: Beauty, grief and faith converge at Charleston’s new Emanuel Nine Memorial, honoring the Black worshippers murdered in a racist attack at Mother Emanuel AME Church in 2015. During an emotional first visit, Rev. Dorothy Boulware reflects on the sacred space, the lives it honors and the profound challenge of finding beauty in a place born of unimaginable sorrow.

The years between that first commitment and the opening required fundraising, craftsmanship and persistence. For those carrying the work forward, they also brought moments when faith felt as tangible as the marble.

The organization’s beginnings trace to meetings between surviving church leaders and community members who felt called to help after the massacre. Before the nonprofit’s formal establishment, The Beach Company partnered with the church to organize executive and design committees. They developed the mission, began fundraising and brought local arts professionals into the planning.

Long Journey to Healing

Formed in 2017, the foundation operates independently of the church. Its board is co-chaired by Mother Emanuel’s senior pastor, the Rev. Eric Manning, and John Darby, CEO of The Beach Company.

Architect Michael Arad, designer of New York’s National September 11 Memorial, was selected that year. His work began with conversations with survivors, families and church members. The memorial would grow from their experiences.

During a Nov. 10 preview, foundation Executive Director Deona Smith explained what the foundation wants those years of work to accomplish.

Moving forward, she said, begins with telling the truth about the past.

These people were more than the way they died

Deona Smith, executive director, Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation

Nine people were murdered in a historic Black church. Their names would remain in the space. Their lives would remain central.

“These people were more than the way they died,” Smith said.

That conviction informed the decision against placing narrative displays about the murders inside the memorial. Historical information and biographies are available through the foundation’s website and app. Smith said families have input into what the foundation shares about their loved ones.

Manning expressed the distinction in remarks reported by Carvd N Stone: “To commemorate is to honor lives rather than center the violence that took them.”

The space also holds Charleston’s history. Smith pointed to the Unity Gates, designed by Carlton Simmons, nephew of famed Charleston blacksmith Philip Simmons. Hearts recall his uncle’s work. A cross, dove, fish and circles carry symbols of faith and community.

Inside the memorial gates, the curved Fellowship Benches suggest wings to some visitors, open arms to others. Smith said each person should experience the memorial on their own terms.

Connecting Through Conversation

Even the team discovered something it had not planned.

Workers standing at opposite ends of a bench realized they could hear one another’s conversations clearly. They called down the length of it, asking the others to speak again. For Smith, the unexpected acoustics suggested another way the space could connect people, sound passing from person to person along the bench.

“So no one is left out of that conversation,” she said.

That invitation carries weight at a church where welcoming a stranger preceded unimaginable violence.

“We cannot allow what happened that day, 11 years ago, to prevent us from still welcoming strangers,” Smith said.

She urged visitors to sit, greet someone they do not know and ask where they come from.

Support came from across the community. Smith identified South Carolina, Charleston and other local governments among its supporters, along with the Ford Foundation, Boeing, businesses and the church itself. The foundation reached its initial $25 million campaign goal.

There were setbacks: Trucking accidents, lost pieces and costs that kept growing. Smith said she could usually enter the construction site focused on the work. The day the fountain arrived was different.

As workers lowered it into place, she recalled, church bells across Charleston began ringing; 11 o’clock, just as the fountain touched down.

“And I was no good at that point,” she said.

Then there was the cross. Smith recalled watching the crane move the Cross of Hope into position as storm clouds rolled away. By the time the cross reached its place, she said, the threatening clouds were gone.

“For me, I believe that it’s God guiding us through this process,” she said.

Next Phase

The foundation’s next phase will honor the five survivors — three adults and two children — in a garden on the opposite side of the church. Five trees and five benches will recognize them individually. A sixth bench will honor Mother Emanuel and its congregation as survivors.

“The courtyard only tells half the story,” Smith said.

The foundation has funds to complete the garden, she said, but seeks another $1 million to absorb unexpected costs. Maintaining the grounds and supporting educational programs will require continuing fundraising.

Smith said lesson plans are being developed for grades three through five and six through 12. A youth program planned for 2027 will give high school juniors and seniors responsibility for creating a social justice or community project. They will choose the project, elect their leaders and manage the work, with adults providing training and guidance.

RELATED: Church Shootings Force Reckoning Between Faith and Security

The goal, Smith said, is “to build their leadership skills, to allow them to use their creativity and to give them voice.”

The foundation began with people determined to preserve nine lives in the nation’s memory. Its next work will ask young people to put that memory into practice.

“The opening on Saturday is not the end,” Smith said before the dedication. “It really is the beginning for us.”