Overview:

Rikers Island has long symbolized racial disparities and institutional violence in New York City. Mamdani's plan promises to close the complex by 2032, but the extended timetable raises questions about the cost of waiting.

For generations, Rikers Island has been a monument to a criminal justice system that has disproportionately incarcerated Black New Yorkers. Since it opened in 1932, the facility’s name itself has become synonymous with violence, neglect and prolonged detention without charge. 

Now, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has unveiled plans to close the notorious jail complex for good. But there’s a catch: Black New Yorkers, who make up more than half of the city’s jail population, may have to wait another six years before Rikers closes its doors.

LEARN MORE: Mamdani Disbands NYPD Unit Accused of Brutalizing Protesters

Mamdani’s 88-page strategic plan, released Friday, would shut down Rikers by Dec. 31, 2032 — more than five years after the legally mandated August 2027 deadline. It calls for replacing the island’s deteriorating facilities with four smaller jails, reducing incarceration and investing in mental health treatment, housing and alternatives to jail.

At a press conference announcing the plan, Mamdani said shuttering the notorious facility is another step toward reforming a system that prioritizes detention over justice. 

“That is why our administration is closing Rikers Island once and for all, and building a city where we ask ourselves what a person needs, not just what they’re accused of,” he said.

Disproportionate Detention

For Black New Yorkers, the stakes are particularly high.

According to the administration’s report, Black people account for almost six in 10 of the city’s jail population, despite representing just 22% of New York City’s residents. Latinos account for roughly a third of Rikers detainees, compared with 28.5% of the city’s population.

The disparities extend beyond the jail cells. Some 65% of the New York City Department of Correction’s uniformed workforce is Black, meaning the violence and dysfunction at Rikers affect Black New Yorkers on both sides of the bars.

The Mamdani administration wants to reduce the jail population from approximately 6,600 people to no more than 4,100 by 2032. The first replacement jail would open in Brooklyn in 2029, followed by facilities in the Bronx and Queens in 2031 and Manhattan in 2032.

That is why our administration is closing Rikers Island once and for all, and building a city where we ask ourselves what a person needs, not just what they’re accused of.

new york city mayor zohran mamdani

The plan includes $290 million in immediate and planned investments through fiscal 2030 to reduce detention, expand supervised release, provide supportive housing and address lengthy court delays. It also calls for 340 beds in therapeutic hospitals for people with serious medical and mental health needs.

But the city’s own statistics suggest the problem is about more than overcrowding.

In 2025, the average length of detention was 102 days, compared with 63 days in 2017. Although pretrial admissions declined by 56% during that period, the jail population fell by just 22%.

Roughly 85% of people in city jails are awaiting trial. More than 840 people detained on murder charges have spent an average of 690 days — around one year, 11 months — in custody awaiting resolution of their cases, according to amNewYork.

Death of Kalief Browder

Those figures underscore a central contradiction: Thousands of New Yorkers remain incarcerated while the courts determine whether they are guilty.

Rikers’ history offers a particularly painful example.

In 2010, Kalief Browder, a Black teenager from the Bronx, was arrested on suspicion of stealing a backpack. Unable to make bail, the 16-year-old spent three years at Rikers, including roughly two years in solitary confinement, before prosecutors dismissed the charges.

Browder died by suicide in 2015, two years after his release. His ordeal helped galvanize the movement to close Rikers, which for decades has been a symbol of institutional abuse and dysfunction in the criminal justice system. 

Mamdani’s proposal has drawn support from Black elected officials, including Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, who has long demanded the jail’s closure.

“Rikers is a moral blight on our city, and closing it is a moral and legal imperative,” Williams said in a statement released by City Hall.

Although he welcomed Mamdani’s commitment, Williams warned that conditions must improve immediately. That includes enforcement of Local Law 42, which restricts solitary confinement.

‘A Stain on Our City’

New York City Council Member Yusef Salaam, one of the Exonerated Five, also endorsed the proposal.

“Rikers Island has been a stain on our city for far too long, and I know that firsthand,” Salaam said in the city’s announcement. “I’m proud to stand with Mayor Mamdani as he lays out a real path to close it for good and build a justice system rooted in dignity, safety and second chances.”

Their support gives Mamdani important Black voices behind a criminal justice initiative that could reshape the relationship between City Hall and communities disproportionately affected by incarceration.

Earlier this year, Tthe mayor also has appointed Stanley Richards to lead the city’s Department of Correction, the first formerly incarcerated person to hold the job. The move placed someone with firsthand experience of the system in charge of reforming it.

Still, critics warn that upgrading aging buildings and spreading the jail population around the boroughs won’t necessarily eliminate the violence associated with Rikers.

Elizabeth Glazer, a former city criminal justice director who helped develop the original closure plan, told Gothamist that without fundamental changes to the Department of Correction, the city risks “merely exporting the violence of Rikers into new ZIP codes.”

The concern is hardly theoretical.

At least nine people have died in city correctional custody this year, according to Gothamist, including one at a newly opened medical facility at Bellevue Hospital and two at borough courthouses. Not all the deaths were homicides, but they underscore the dangers that persist beyond Rikers itself.

RELATED: After Losing Their Children to Police Violence, These Mothers Are Fighting for Change 

For Mamdani, the plan offers a chance to make good on a campaign promise while showing his administration can deliver meaningful change to Black communities.

For Black New Yorkers, however, the measure of success may be less complicated: Fewer people incarcerated without conviction, shorter waits for justice and an end to the violence that has defined Rikers for generations.

A veteran journalist, political analyst, and essayist, Joseph Williams has been published in a wide range of publications, including The New York Times, The Washington Post, Politico, The Boston Globe, The Atlantic, and US News & World Report. A California native, Williams is a graduate of the University Of Richmond and a former Nieman Fellow at Harvard University. He lives and works in metro Washington, D.C.