Overview:

Charleston's new Emanuel Nine Memorial is breathtaking in its beauty and heartbreaking in its necessity. Rev. Dorothy Boulware reflects on the architecture, spiritual symbolism and lives remembered in a sacred space born from racist violence.

I was honored to be among the first journalists to see the Emanuel Nine Memorial in Charleston, South Carolina, during a preview just days before its public opening last week.

It was breathtaking. It wasn’t until I walked through the iron gates and into the bright white, incredible, artistic outdoor memorial that my breath and words began to flow.

I saw a birth canal and, from the same stance, the gates of heaven. In that moment, the entirety of life seemed captured and revealed. Started and stopped – like my breath and my words.

This memorial grew from an encounter with the unholy combination of love and hate, of life and death, of purity and confusion. More than a decade after the murders that made this sacred remembrance necessary, the memorial stands on the grounds of Mother Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, where, on June 17, 2015, a 21-year-old white supremacist shared in Bible study with church members before pulling out a handgun and opening fire.

Nine were killed. Five others survived.

Before I could describe what had been built, I had to reckon with why it was necessary. Nine people had gone to church. To Bible study. To a place where opening the door to a stranger fit the faith they had gathered to practice.

Eleven years later, their names belong to a place built to receive people who may never have known them, but who must know that they lived.

The Rev. Sharonda Coleman-Singleton. Cynthia Graham Hurd. Susie Jackson. Ethel Lee Lance. The Rev. DePayne Middleton-Doctor. The Rev. Clementa C. Pinckney. Tywanza Sanders. The Rev. Daniel L. Simmons Sr. Myra Quarles Thompson. 

Each one belonged to a life before it belonged to a memorial. Each one was spoken in love, called across a room, written on something ordinary. Each one still belongs to people who know precisely what is missing.

That is part of what makes this memorial’s beauty so difficult to receive. The eye delights in what the heart wishes there had never been a reason to create.

The man who gave this space its form is architect Michael Arad, a partner at Handel Architects and the designer of the National September 11 Memorial in New York City. He was selected for the Emanuel Nine project in 2017. 

That is part of what makes this memorial’s beauty so difficult to receive. The eye delights in what the heart wishes there had never been a reason to create.

The design story includes the people who trusted him with their memories. Arad met with relatives of those killed, survivors, and members of the congregation. He listened to stories of the people they loved and the lives they had shared. Those gatherings helped shape the memorial. The Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation has led the effort to bring it into being. 

Making something beautiful from another person’s sorrow carries a responsibility. The people who live with the loss must have room in the telling. At the center of Arad’s design is the Memorial Courtyard. Two fellowship benches face one another, their high backs rising and curving around the space. The entrance opens outward to welcome visitors. The memorial’s designer describes the curves as sheltering wings, an embrace around those who enter. 

Fellowship benches. Even the name gives me pause. Fellowship was part of what brought the worshippers together that Wednesday evening. And here, facing benches make room for people to sit in one another’s presence again. I think of how much of church life happens that way. Sitting beside somebody. Listening. Allowing a person to be quiet without requiring an explanation.

Within the curve of the benches is the Fountain of Grace, its marble bearing the names of the nine. Water begins flowing from a cross-shaped source, fills the basin, and spills gently over their names. 

I think of baptism. I think of tears. I think of all the times we reach for water when words have exhausted themselves, when somebody needs a cool cloth, a drink, a moment to breathe.

My minister’s heart and my human heart reach for language together.

Toward the rear of the courtyard, an opening between the benches reveals a cross above a simple altar. Called the Cross of Hope, it offers another place for contemplation and prayer. 

I have stood before crosses for much of my life. Preached beneath them. Prayed in their presence. Still, in the context of these nine lives, I cannot hurry past what the cross asks a Christian to consider about suffering, love and the promises we continue to hold.

The memorial’s plans also make room for those who lived through the attack. A separate Survivors’ Garden is planned as a second phase, with completion hoped for by the end of 2028, according to foundation executive director Deona Smith. Its design includes five trees honoring the five survivors and six benches, with the additional bench recognizing the church itself as a survivor. 

A congregation has had to continue living here. Worshipping here. Carrying memories into the same church where it carries its prayers.

I came to write about what had been created. I am still searching for words enough to hold what it means that the memorial had to be.

For now, I return to the opening. To the birth canal. To the gates of heaven.

And to the nine names at the center of it all.